The Hospital Extraction Machine

In September 2025, Harvard Medical School researchers published a study in the Annals of Internal Medicine comparing outcomes at 49 private equity-owned hospitals against 293 matched controls, using more than 1 million emergency department visits and 121,000 intensive care unit hospitalizations from Medicare claims data spanning 2009 to 2019. Harvard Medical School

The finding: private equity-owned hospitals had 7 additional deaths per 10,000 emergency room visits — a 13 percent increase over the baseline. The researchers identified the mechanism. Post-acquisition, PE-owned hospitals cut emergency room salary expenditures by 18 percent and intensive care unit salary expenditures by 16 percent. The money saved on staffing produced a corresponding increase in people who died.

A 2023 study in the Journal of the American Medical Association found a 25 percent increase in adverse patient events — hospital-acquired infections, patient falls, pressure ulcers — at PE-owned hospitals within three years of acquisition. JAMA These are not unintended consequences. They are the product of a deliberate financial architecture: buy the hospital, load it with debt, extract value through management fees and sale-leaseback deals, resolve the resulting cash pressure by cutting clinical staff.

In 2010, Cerberus Capital Management acquired the Archdiocese of Boston's nonprofit hospital system, Caritas Christi Health Care, and converted it to for-profit. The new company was called Steward Health Care. Its chief executive was Ralph de la Torre. Over the next 14 years, Cerberus and de la Torre collectively extracted approximately $1.3 billion from Steward through management fees, dividend recapitalizations funded by borrowed money, and sale-leaseback transactions that sold the hospital buildings to a real estate investment trust and left Steward paying rent on facilities it no longer owned. The sale-leaseback deals alone locked Steward into $6.6 billion in long-term rent obligations. PESP

Steward filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy on May 6, 2024 — the largest hospital system bankruptcy in United States history, with approximately $9.2 billion in total liabilities. Five hospitals permanently closed. Among them: Carney Hospital in Dorchester, Massachusetts — located in Boston's lowest-income neighborhood — and Nashoba Valley Medical Center in Ayer, Massachusetts, which had served 115,000 residents across 17 rural communities, handling 16,000 emergency room visits per year. Nashoba's closure sent patients to emergency rooms 15 to 20 miles away. Commonwealth Beacon

During the Senate hearing on Steward's collapse, Senator Bernie Sanders displayed a photograph of de la Torre's 190-foot, $40 million yacht. De la Torre also owns a $15 million sportfishing boat and a mansion in Dallas. CBS Boston The Senate HELP Committee issued its first subpoena since 1981 compelling de la Torre to testify. He refused to appear, calling the hearing a "pseudo-criminal proceeding." The Committee voted 20 to 0 — unanimous — to refer both criminal and civil contempt charges. The full Senate gave unanimous consent to hold him in contempt of Congress. De la Torre resigned as CEO and filed a lawsuit against the Committee. FierceHealthcare No criminal charges have been filed.

Leonard Green and Partners acquired Prospect Medical Holdings in 2010 and held its majority stake until 2021. During that period, Leonard Green extracted $424 million in dividends from the hospital operator. The 2018 dividend recapitalization alone moved $457 million in a single transaction — funded by debt loaded onto Prospect Medical's hospitals. Sam Lee, Prospect's chief executive, personally received approximately $90 million from that transaction. CBS News

The Senate Budget Committee's bipartisan investigation concluded that Leonard Green "wielded substantial influence over" Prospect Medical's financial decisions and "incentivized" management "to satisfy LGP's financial goals regardless of patient outcomes." Multiple health and safety violations were documented during the ownership period. Senate Budget Committee

Prospect Medical Holdings filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in 2025. Taylor Hospital in Ridley Park, Pennsylvania closed April 26, 2025. Crozer-Chester Medical Center in Upland, Pennsylvania closed May 2, 2025. Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro said Prospect had "pillaged these hospitals for their own gain." The state and county provided $40 million in emergency funding to find a buyer. No viable buyer emerged. Pennsylvania Capital-Star Delaware County — 576,000 residents — went from four emergency rooms to two. 2,651 workers were laid off. PESP No criminal charges have been filed against Sam Lee or Leonard Green.

Apollo Global Management manages approximately $671 billion in assets. It owns Lifepoint Health, which operates the nation's largest network of rural hospitals. The Senate Budget Committee's bipartisan investigation found that patient volumes at Lifepoint "shriveled" under Apollo ownership: emergency department wait times increased, transfers to other hospitals increased, and the company struggled to recruit and retain clinical staff. Senate Budget Committee

Apollo charges Lifepoint $9.2 million annually in management fees — money drawn from the hospital operator's operating revenue before clinical needs are funded. Apollo also charges a 1 percent transaction fee on every acquisition Lifepoint makes. PESP At Ottumwa Regional Health Center in rural Iowa, Senate investigators concluded that patient safety events "may have occurred because of unfulfilled promises and underinvestment, which eroded the hospital's culture of safety." Marc Rowan, Apollo's chief executive, has a personal net worth of approximately $8 to $10 billion. No criminal charges have been filed.

Every major hospital extraction follows the same three-step architecture:

Sale-leaseback. The PE firm sells the hospital's physical buildings to a real estate investment trust, pocketing the cash immediately. The hospital then pays rent on facilities it previously owned outright. Steward sold its buildings to Medical Properties Trust and locked itself into $6.6 billion in rent obligations. The upfront cash went to Cerberus and de la Torre. The rent payments went out of hospitals' operating budgets for the next decade.

Dividend recapitalization. The firm takes on new debt — in the hospital's name — and uses the borrowed money to pay itself a dividend. Sam Lee's 2018 extraction was $457 million borrowed against Prospect Medical's future revenue. Leonard Green got $257 million. Sam Lee got $90 million. The hospitals got the debt.

Management fees. The PE firm charges the hospital system an annual fee — nominally for "management services" — that draws cash out of clinical operations every year, regardless of whether the hospitals are profitable. Apollo charges Lifepoint $9.2 million per year. These fees are paid before nurses, before supplies, before capital maintenance.

Together, these mechanisms transfer value from the hospital to the PE firm and its investors. When the resulting debt becomes unpayable, the hospital files for bankruptcy, the PE firm has already exited with its returns, and the communities served by those hospitals — disproportionately low-income, rural, and underinsured — lose their emergency rooms.

In January 2025, the Senate Budget Committee — chaired by Sheldon Whitehouse (Democrat, Rhode Island) and ranking member Chuck Grassley (Republican, Iowa) — released a yearlong bipartisan investigation titled "Profits Over Patients." It examined three PE-owned hospital systems in depth: Cerberus/Steward, Leonard Green/Prospect, and Apollo/Lifepoint. The committee's finding: "PE-owned hospitals shown to harm patients, degrade care, and drive hospital closures." The report was bipartisan. It was based on a year of investigation. It named names and cited figures. Senate Budget Committee

The Senate HELP Committee issued its first subpoena since 1981 to compel testimony. The chief executive refused to appear, was held in contempt by a 20-to-0 vote, and responded by filing a lawsuit against the Committee. Two hospitals in Boston's poorest neighborhoods remain closed. Delaware County has two emergency rooms for 576,000 people. Rural Iowans wait longer in ERs that charge annual management fees to a firm managing $671 billion.

No executive from Cerberus, Leonard Green, or Apollo has been charged with a crime.

The extraction is not a malfunction. The hospitals closed because the money was successfully removed. Carney Hospital in Dorchester. Nashoba Valley in Ayer. Taylor Hospital in Ridley Park. Crozer-Chester in Upland. The communities they served did not fail these hospitals. The Senate's 'Profits Over Patients' report is 200 pages. The criminal charges filed: zero.